Cloud Atlas - David Mitchell
This is the first of the 2004 Booker short list I have read, and I am going to stick my neck out and predict that it will be the winner. Cloud Atlas is 6 seperate stories intertwined. Each of the narratives is set in a different time and place, each is written in a different prose style, and all but one are broken off mid-action and brought to conclusion in the second half of the book.
The books most entertaining episodes are a collection of letters from the 1930s detailing a young musician's effort to become an amanuensis for a renowned, blind composer, a modern day political intrigure murder mystery, and a hilarious account of a pompus modern-day vanity publisher who is institutionalized by mistake and his efforts to escape. The two weakest links for me were the Sci Fi story of a future where coporations run what is left of the planet and use clones as slaves (Mitchell keeps trying - and failing - to be Murakami), and a story about life at the end of civilization. It all adds up to a book which is both adventurous, dazzling, entertaining, and at times infuriating.
At times I felt I was being tricked into accepting the book as a novel and not the collection of short stories which it arguably is, such are the very weak connections between the episodes and the rather lame re-incarnation theme that also appears. Indeed I found myself thinking of Charles Palliser's playful book 'Betrayals' on more than one occasion, which also made me feel the same way.
That said, Mitchell's writing is impressive, and although some of his voices are less convincing than others, when this book is good, it is very good. But there for me is the problem; whilst it is a good book, I don't think it is a good novel, because it failed to work for me as a novel, and indeed reading the better episodes as individual self contained stories was far more satisfying.
The books most entertaining episodes are a collection of letters from the 1930s detailing a young musician's effort to become an amanuensis for a renowned, blind composer, a modern day political intrigure murder mystery, and a hilarious account of a pompus modern-day vanity publisher who is institutionalized by mistake and his efforts to escape. The two weakest links for me were the Sci Fi story of a future where coporations run what is left of the planet and use clones as slaves (Mitchell keeps trying - and failing - to be Murakami), and a story about life at the end of civilization. It all adds up to a book which is both adventurous, dazzling, entertaining, and at times infuriating.
At times I felt I was being tricked into accepting the book as a novel and not the collection of short stories which it arguably is, such are the very weak connections between the episodes and the rather lame re-incarnation theme that also appears. Indeed I found myself thinking of Charles Palliser's playful book 'Betrayals' on more than one occasion, which also made me feel the same way.
That said, Mitchell's writing is impressive, and although some of his voices are less convincing than others, when this book is good, it is very good. But there for me is the problem; whilst it is a good book, I don't think it is a good novel, because it failed to work for me as a novel, and indeed reading the better episodes as individual self contained stories was far more satisfying.